Toyota Built a Bigger Highlander. Was That the Problem?
The 2024 Grand Highlander costs up to $62K and seats 8. But depreciation, fuel costs, and a confusing trim ladder make the math harder than Toyota wants you to think.
The 2026 Toyota 4Runner ditched its ancient V6 for a turbo four. We break down real ownership costs, what changed, and who should actually buy one.
Want to see the exact numbers for your situation?
Run the comparison →Advertisement
After two decades of selling essentially the same truck to people who either loved it or tolerated it, Toyota rebuilt the 4Runner from the ground up for 2025. The 2026 model carries that forward. The surprising part is not that they updated it. The surprising part is what they replaced the engine with: a turbocharged 2.4-liter four-cylinder in a vehicle that starts near $40,000 and competes against six-cylinder and V8 rivals. That choice runs through every conversation about this truck, including this one.
The 4Runner is a body-on-frame, mid-size SUV built for people who take it off pavement. Not "off pavement" as in a gravel parking lot at a state park. Actually off pavement. Rock crawling, forest roads, river crossings. The kind of driving that destroys crossovers.
Toyota has always sold this truck to a specific buyer: someone who wants genuine trail capability, long-term mechanical reliability, and enough daily usability to drive it to work on Mondays. The 4Runner has historically been one of the highest-resale vehicles on the market, which makes the sticker price sting less over time.
Who should skip it: anyone who drives mostly on highways, who cares deeply about fuel economy, who wants a quiet cabin, or who needs more than 32 cubic feet of cargo space behind the rear seats. There are better answers for all of those people. The 4Runner does not pretend otherwise, or at least it should not.
This is where you either trust Toyota's engineering history or you do not.
The 2026 4Runner drops the old 4.0-liter V6 entirely. Every trim now runs a 2.4-liter turbocharged four-cylinder engine, the same i-FORCE MAX family used in the Tacoma and RAV4 Prime. Two versions are offered. The standard setup produces 278 horsepower and 317 lb-ft of torque, paired with an 8-speed automatic transmission. An available hybrid version, called i-FORCE MAX, adds an electric motor and bumps output to 326 horsepower and 465 lb-ft of torque.
That torque number on the hybrid is genuinely useful off-road, since electric motors deliver full torque immediately at low speeds.
Fuel economy from the EPA shakes out as follows:
Neither number is impressive for a vehicle in this class. The Ford Bronco and Jeep Wrangler are similarly thirsty, so this is more an indictment of the segment than the 4Runner specifically. But if you are coming from a V6-powered anything and expecting improvement, do not.
Toyota offers the 4Runner in several trims. You can configure your own at Toyota's build page.
| Trim | MSRP (est.) | What You Actually Get |
|---|---|---|
| SR5 | ~$40,000 | Base trail capability, basic infotainment, cloth seats, 4WD |
| TRD Sport | ~$44,000 | Sport-tuned suspension (odd for off-road use), gloss black trim |
| TRD Off-Road | ~$46,500 | Multi-terrain select, locking rear diff, crawl control, better approach angles |
| Limited | ~$52,000 | Leather, premium audio, more tech, less off-road focus |
| TRD Pro | ~$58,000 | Fox shocks, extra lift, i-FORCE MAX hybrid standard, full serious hardware |
| Trailhunter | ~$60,000 | Overland-ready from the factory, ARB gear, roof rack, rugged appearance package |
The TRD Off-Road trim is the honest buy for most people who actually want to go off-road without paying TRD Pro prices. The Limited is for people who want a nice interior and have decided against a Land Cruiser or a Lexus GX. The Trailhunter is Toyota trying to capture the overlanding crowd before they spend that money at an aftermarket shop.
The interior is finally respectable. The previous generation had a dashboard that looked borrowed from a 2009 rental car. The 2026 model gets an 8-inch standard or available 14-inch touchscreen, wireless Apple CarPlay and Android Auto, and a cabin that does not feel embarrassing next to a $50,000 price tag.
The off-road hardware on the right trims is still class-leading. Multi-terrain select, crawl control, and a proper locking rear differential are features that Jeep charges extra for and Ford offers on only specific Bronco packages. The approach and departure angles are better than the old generation. Ground clearance is up.
The standard Toyota Safety Sense suite covers pre-collision braking, lane departure alert, adaptive cruise, and automatic high beams. That is table stakes in 2026, but it is there.
Seat comfort is improved. The old 4Runner's front seats were tolerable at best. The new ones are better bolstered and hold you more securely on uneven terrain, which is the point.
The four-cylinder engine sounds wrong in a truck this big and this expensive. That is partly emotional and partly real. When you are at highway speeds and ask for passing power, there is a pause and a surge that feels less settled than the old V6. Toyota will tell you the numbers are better. They are. But refinement is not just about numbers.
The standard 2.4T also does not get the hybrid's torque, which means the trim most people buy, the TRD Off-Road, delivers less low-end grunt than the $10,000-more-expensive TRD Pro. If you want the best powertrain for actual off-road use, you are paying for TRD Pro.
The cargo area is still not large. At 32.4 cubic feet behind the rear seats, it trails rivals. The Kia Telluride offers nearly double that, though that is a different kind of vehicle entirely.
Road noise is noticeable on highways. The 4Runner was never quiet, and the new one is better, but it is still loud by modern standards. Long highway trips will wear on you.
As of this writing, the 2026 4Runner has not yet received full crash test ratings from NHTSA or IIHS. The platform is shared with the fifth-generation model that launched in 2025, and ratings for that vehicle are still pending in some categories. Check both sites directly before purchase. This is not a small thing to skip.
Using the TRD Off-Road trim at approximately $46,500 as the reference point:
Depreciation: New vehicles typically lose 15 to 22 percent in the first year. Toyota 4Runners historically depreciate at the low end of that range due to strong demand. Call it 15 percent. That is roughly $6,975 in lost value in year one. This is where the 4Runner's reputation for holding value actually saves you money compared to, say, a Jeep Wrangler or a Bronco Sport.
Fuel: At 15,000 miles per year and 23 mpg combined, you are buying about 652 gallons of gas. At the current national average of $3.30 per gallon, that is approximately $2,150 per year.
Insurance: A mid-trim 4Runner typically runs $1,600 to $2,400 per year depending on your location, driving history, and coverage level. Urban drivers with less than five years of clean history should expect the higher end.
First service interval: Toyota recommends oil changes every 10,000 miles with synthetic oil. Expect one oil change plus a tire rotation at about 5,000 miles for roughly $100 to $140 at a Toyota dealer.
Rough year-one total: $10,825 to $11,665, not counting the down payment or loan interest. That number is average for the class. It is not cheap.
Ford Bronco: The 4Runner wins on long-term reliability track record and resale value. The Bronco wins on driver engagement, more transmission choices, and a more modern interior at a similar price.
Jeep Wrangler: The 4Runner wins on everyday livability, quieter cabin, and better highway manners. The Wrangler wins on raw off-road capability, removable doors and roof, and a more devoted community of aftermarket support.
Lexus GX: The 4Runner wins on price and off-road trim availability. The Lexus GX wins on everything related to interior comfort, refinement, and the feeling that $60,000 was well spent.
The 4Runner is a good truck for a specific kind of person. If you go off-road regularly, need a vehicle that will last 200,000 miles with reasonable maintenance costs, and can accept a fuel bill and highway noise level that would annoy most modern SUV buyers, this is one of the better choices on the market.
Buy it if you are choosing between this and a Jeep Wrangler and you want more comfort. Buy it if you value resale value so much that it actually factors into your budget math. Buy the TRD Off-Road or TRD Pro, not the Limited, unless you genuinely prefer leather seats to a locking differential.
Skip it if you spend most of your time on highways and want a quiet, efficient SUV. A Kia Telluride or a Hyundai Palisade will serve you better for less money. Skip it if the four-cylinder engine still bothers you after a test drive. That feeling will not improve on your commute. Skip it if you are drawn to the Trailhunter purely on looks, because you are paying a premium for factory accessories you could buy yourself for less.
The 4Runner got modern. Whether it got modern enough depends entirely on what you needed from it in the first place.
Advertisement
The 2024 Grand Highlander costs up to $62K and seats 8. But depreciation, fuel costs, and a confusing trim ladder make the math harder than Toyota wants you to think.
The 2024 Tacoma ditched its old V6 for a turbo four-cylinder. Real-world fuel economy, first-year ownership costs, and who should actually buy one.
The 2022 Toyota Highlander runs $32K–$42K used. Here's what you'll actually spend on fuel, repairs, and the problems that show up after 60k miles.